The vocabulary first, because mixing these up is the single most common way agencies underprice themselves. The pay rate is what the contractor receives. The bill rate is what you invoice the client. The markup is the percentage you add to the pay rate to get the bill rate: bill rate equals pay rate times one plus markup. A $65 pay rate at a 45 percent markup bills at $94.25.
The $29.25 spread between those two numbers is not profit. Watch where it goes on that $65 contractor:
| Component | Per hour | What it covers |
|---|---|---|
| Pay to the contractor | $65.00 | Gross wages |
| Employer FICA | $4.97 | 7.65% Social Security and Medicare |
| Unemployment insurance | $0.30-$0.90 | FUTA plus your state rate |
| Workers comp | $0.30-$1.00 | Priced off the job class code |
| Benefits and leave | $2.00-$4.00 | Health plan, sick leave accrual |
| Left for the agency | ~$18-$21 | Recruiting, back office, profit |
That is the number to internalize: a 45 percent markup leaves roughly $20 an hour for everything the agency does, and the statutory burden alone eats about $8 of the $29 spread before you have paid a recruiter anything. This is also why markup is not margin. A 65 percent markup sounds rich until you express it as share of the bill rate: it is 39.4 percent, and most of that is spoken for.
Where the market actually sits
Published benchmarks for 2026 put IT contract markups between 35 and 50 percent, with general staffing running 25 to 75 percent depending on the role. Robert Half's pricing under a Texas purchasing cooperative sets 70 percent for IT and 65 percent for administrative roles. One national staffing firm publishes 50 to 85 percent based on skill level and contract length. These are real filed numbers, not survey vibes.
My decision rule for setting yours: start from the burden, not the benchmark. Add up your per-hour statutory costs for the role and state, add what the placement actually cost you to fill, add the margin you need, then divide by the pay rate. If that number comes out below 35 percent on a technical role, you have probably forgotten a cost, because the market data says almost nobody sustains below that. If a client pushes you under your floor, the honest move is to renegotiate the pay rate down, not to compress the markup, since the burden does not compress.
Two adjustments to the base. Short assignments cost more per hour: one staffing firm's terms allow up to 150 percent markup when the assignment totals under 40 hours, because recruiting costs the same for two days as for two months. And scarce skills carry a premium for the screening effort; the five point gap between administrative and IT rates in the Robert Half filing is the market pricing exactly that.
Quote markup, track margin
Agencies quote markup to clients and track margin internally, and confusing the two is how profitable-looking deals go red. Margin is what is left of the bill rate after every cost, and it is the number that connects to the rest of your P&L. A 45 percent markup that leaves $20 an hour sounds fine until utilization drops to 60 percent, at which point the bench cost eats the margin without touching the markup. The utilization benchmarks and the margin benchmarks belong next to this piece, not instead of it.
For fixed-fee project work the same burden logic applies in a different shape: the contractor cost is your delivery cost, and the markup thinking becomes the margin target you set before pricing. I walked through that direction in setting hourly rates from a target margin. And when the client starts adding work after the SOW is signed, the spread you protected here is exactly what scope creep eats first.
The edge case nobody models: conversion fees. When a client hires your contractor permanently, the fee is typically 15 to 25 percent of first-year salary, and it arrives as a lump that can dwarf months of markup. Price your contract terms so a conversion is a win, not a surprise, and run every new placement through the margin calculator before you sign.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good markup on a contractor's pay rate?
For IT and professional roles, 40 to 60 percent is the normal band; general staffing runs 25 to 75 percent. Below 35 percent on technical roles is hard to sustain once payroll taxes, insurance, and recruiting are counted. Compute your floor from your actual burden costs rather than picking a benchmark.
How do you calculate bill rate from pay rate and markup?
Bill rate equals pay rate times one plus the markup. A $65 pay rate at 45 percent markup bills at $94.25 an hour. To find markup from existing rates: subtract pay rate from bill rate, then divide by pay rate.
Is markup the same as profit margin?
No. Markup is measured against the pay rate; margin is measured against the bill rate. A 65 percent markup equals 39.4 percent of the bill rate before any payroll tax or insurance is paid. Quote markup, track margin.
Why is the markup higher for short assignments?
Recruiting, onboarding, and compliance cost the agency the same whether the assignment lasts two days or two months. Short engagements spread those fixed costs over fewer billable hours, so the per-hour markup has to be higher. Terms allowing up to 150 percent on sub-40-hour assignments reflect that.
What does the markup actually pay for?
Employer payroll taxes (7.65 percent FICA plus unemployment), workers compensation, benefits the agency offers, recruiting and screening, payroll administration, insurance, and the agency's profit. On a typical placement, statutory costs alone consume roughly a quarter to a third of the spread.